Lord Pannick QC
- Called to Bar:
- 1979
- Appointed to silk:
- 1992
- Practice areas:
- Degrees:
- MA (Oxon), BCL (Oxon)
- Languages:
-
French (fluent)
Lord Pannick QC's practice covers a broad range of areas including Public law & Human Rights, Media & Entertainment, Employment & Discrimination, Sports law, EU & Competition, including the European Convention on Human Rights, Professional Discipline and Telecommunications. Much of his work has a Public law & Human Rights dimension and a selection of some significant cases are given below, under this heading.
In Chambers UK 2010 Lord Pannick QC is rated as a leading silk in eight practice areas and is recognised as one of its “stars at the bar”:
- Administration & Public Law – David Pannick QC is perhaps the most well-known and in-demand public law barrister in the country. Clients asserted: "He is the must-use barrister for when the stakes are at their highest."
- Employment – tackles employment cases in the context of a wider public law context. "Superb at whatever he turns his hand to."
- EU & Competition - one of the leading barristers of his generation. Pannick is "amazing at whatever he does as he can boil down the most complicated material to 20-minute submissions."
- Human Rights & Civil Liberties – He is a simply [an] outstanding advocate with a peerless track record.
- Immigration & Nationality – David Pannick QC receives such rave reviews for his varied practice that interviewees begin to run out of superlatives. One observer commented: "Obviously Pannick is superb – you won’t find anyone who disputes that."
- Professional Discipline - "legal genius"
- Sport - "one of the all-time greatest advocates" and sources say that "he is probably the brightest administrative leader of his generation."
- Telecommunications – "intellectually commanding, incisive and confident"
Lord Pannick QC is recognised by Legal 500 2009 as a ‘Leading Silk’ in five areas:
- Administrative and Public law – "remains in a league of his own"
- Human Rights and Civil Liberties – "first-rate advocate"
- Immigration – "incredibly professional"
- Media, Entertainment and Sport – successfully represented the British Olympic Committee.
- Professional Discipline and Regulatory law – "his experience is unrivalled"
The Times Law 100 2009 listing the most influential lawyers in Britain ranked Lord Pannick QC in 9th place. He "remains among the handful of QCs in the alpha-league that makes them in highest demand".
In November 2008, he became a Life Peer, sitting on the crossbenches, while continuing in full-time practice at the Bar.
Professional Experience
Junior Counsel to the Crown (Common Law) 1988-1992
Fellow of All Souls College, Oxford, since 1978
Honorary Fellow of Hertford College, Oxford since September 2004
Administrative Law Bar Association
Member of the Editorial Board of Public Law
Member of the Constitution Committee of the House of Lords since 2009
Public Law and Human Rights
Current and recent work
- Represented the Crown in the Court of Appeal in establishing that MPs and a Peer being prosecuted for alleged dishonesty in the claiming of Parliamentary expenses were not entitled to Parliamentary privilege.
- Appeared in the first hearing in the new Supreme Court in October 2009 on behalf of JFS, a school being sued by a boy seeking admission.
- Acting for Debbie Purdy who established that the DPP has a duty to publish guidelines concerning his power to prosecute those who help relatives to go abroad for an assisted suicide. This was the last judgment in the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords in July 2009, before the opening of the new Supreme Court.
- Representing AF, a person subject to a control order because of alleged involvement in terrorist activities. Nine Law Lords held in June 2009 that he was entitled to know the essence of the allegations against him.
- Acting for the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police in the House of Lords in establishing that it was not a breach of the European Convention on Human Rights for the police to cordon off demonstrators in Oxford Circus for several hours during the May Day 2001 demonstrations.
- Acting for Sir David Barclay and Sir Frederick Barclay in establishing in the Court of Appeal that the Seneschal of Sark could not lawfully sit as a judge in Sark and also as the presiding office in the Sark legislature.
- Representing the British Olympic Committee in July 2008 in resisting the application by athlete Dwain Chambers for an injunction to overturn the lifelong ban on him competing at the Olympic Games by reason of an earlier doping offence.
- Appearing for the pharmaceutical company, Eisai, in persuading the Court of Appeal that NICE acted in a procedurally unfair manner and so unlawfully in refusing to provide on the NHS drugs for patients suffering from Alzheimer's disease.
Lord Pannick appeared in 100 cases in the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords (before it was replaced by the new Supreme Court), and has argued more than 25 cases in the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg and over 30 cases in the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg.
He has acted in a large number of the leading public law cases of the last 25 years :
- In Spycatcher, he acted for The Sunday Times
- He represented Tiny Rowland and Lonrho plc in the battle with Mohammed Al-Fayed concerning the take-over of Harrods.
- In ex parte Bentley, he persuaded the Divisional Court on behalf of Iris Bentley that the Home Secretary should give a posthumous pardon to her brother, Derek Bentley, for his execution in 1953.
- He acted in the European Court of Human Rights for the gay servicemen who established that it was a breach of their human rights to exclude gays from the military : Lustig-Prean v United Kingdom.
- He represented the Home Secretary in successfully establishing in the House of Lords the legality of the whole life tariff for Myra Hindley, the Moors Murderer.
- He acted for the Home Secretary in the domestic courts and in the European Court of Human Rights in proceedings brought by Robert Thompson and Jon Venables, the boys who murdered the infant James Bulger, challenging their sentences of detention during Her Majesty's pleasure.
- He represented the Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority in the case brought by Diane Blood who wished to be impregnated with the sperm of her dead husband, and in the House of Lords case which established the right of parents to obtain fertility treatment to have a child so cells from the umbilical cord could assist their severely ill son ("the designer baby case").
- He successfully represented the BBC in the Divisional Court in resisting the contention that the Director-General had committed the criminal offence of blasphemy by broadcasting "Jerry Springer - The Opera". (Following the judgment, Parliament decided to abolish the criminal offence of blasphemy).
- He acted for Camelot in its successful judicial review challenge to the National Lottery Commission in 2000.
His clients have included:
- The Queen - winning an injunction in the High Court to restrain The Daily Mirror from publishing further allegations about her home life by a reporter who had gained employment as a footman.
- Greg Rusedski - at a tennis tribunal in Montreal, defeating allegations that he was guilty of a doping office.
- Ann Marie Rogers - who established in the Court of Appeal her right to be provided with the breast cancer drug, Herceptin.
- The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia - in establishing in the House of Lords that state immunity applies to claims alleging torture.
- The League Against Cruel Sports - in successfully resisting the challenge to the Hunting Act 2004.
- Sheptonhurst Ltd - who defeated the British Board of Film Classification in establishing the right to buy, in licensed sex shops, videos of "Nympho Nurse Nancy" and "Horny Catbabe", and so substantially liberalising the laws on censorship of explicit sexual material.
He has also appeared in court for a wide range of other clients, from the Revd Moon to the Chief Rabbi, from Red Hot Television to the Lord Chancellor, from Diana Princess of Wales to Lord Rees-Mogg.
In Strasbourg, he has appeared in cases (for and against the United Kingdom Government) raising issues on the rights of transsexuals, sadomasochists, gypsies and many others. He acted for Greece in resisting the claim brought by former King Constantine for the return of property, and he represented Cyprus in relation to human rights abuses by Turkey in Northern Cyprus.
He has appeared in a large number of cases in the courts of Hong Kong, and in the courts of Brunei, the Cayman Islands, and Gibraltar.
Other relevant experience
Publications:
Judicial Review of the Death Penalty (1982, Duckworth)
Sex Discrimination Law (1985, Oxford University Press)
Judges (1987, Oxford University Press)
Advocates (1992, Oxford University Press)
Human Rights Law and Practice (general editor with Lord Lester of Herne Hill QC, Butterworths, October 1999 and second edition March 2004). The third edition was published in May 2009 (general editor with Lord Lester of Herne Hill QC and Javan Herberg).
A fortnightly legal column in The Times (since 1991)
