Carmine has a broad practice covering all of Chambers’ main practice areas, with a focus on commercial matters.

Before being called to the Bar, Carmine practised as a solicitor at Arnold Bloch Leibler, Melbourne. He maintained a broad commercial litigation practice in all Federal and Victorian courts and tribunals.  Carmine advised on a range of high-profile and complex disputes for leading corporates and high net worth individuals.

Carmine is also a former Senior Lecturer in Private Law at Keble College, Oxford, and a former Law Fellow and Director of Studies at Homerton College, Cambridge.  He taught subjects including Contract Law, Equity, Trusts and Legal Reasoning. Carmine’s research has been published in leading journals including the Law Quarterly Review, Lloyds Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly and the Restitution Law Review.

Carmine remains an Australian Legal Practitioner and is able to advise on Australian law.

Experience

Shortlist

Commercial

Carmine accepts instructions in all areas of Chambers’ commercial litigation practice. His commercial law practice draws on his considerable experience as a solicitor, and his academic research and teaching experience.

As to the former, whilst a commercial litigator Carmine was involved in a broad range of commercial disputes and advisory work, including several high-value and complex commercial matters. For example, he acted for:

  • one of Australia’s largest telecommunication corporations regarding its disputes with domestic and international business partners, suppliers and consumers;
  • a leading commercial building surveying company in a dispute with its former accountants which raised difficult questions of breach of fiduciary duty, negligence and causation; and
  • a high net worth individual in a multimillion-dollar damages claim against his former building contractor arising out of failed real estate development.

As to the latter, Carmine’s doctoral thesis examined the remedies of relief against penalties and relief against forfeiture, and several forms of damages, in a commercial context.  His publications have covered various contract law and restitution doctrines, and equitable remedies.  Carmine has also taught Contract Law, Equity and Trusts.

Cases

Grid view
List view
Shortlist

Civil Fraud, Asset Recovery & Injunctive Relief

Carmine accepts instructions in all areas of Chambers’ civil fraud practice.  He was worked on a number of multi-jurisdictional fraud claims, often raising complex private international law issues. 

As a commercial litigator, Carmine advised banks, business leaders and corporations in several complicated civil fraud and asset-tracing and recovery matters.  For instance, he represented:

  • several Singaporean banks in a multimillion-dollar, long-running case involving allegations of fraud and breach of fiduciary duty, and an application for a third-party debt order;
  • a leading merchant banker in a high-value deceit claim arising out of an alleged fraud regarding a ski resort development, which proceeding included an application for an ex parte injunction and a search order; and
  • a major Australian corporation in an extended Australian Federal Police investigation, in which the AFP alleged among other things fraud and bribery. 

Further, Carmine’s research on equitable remedies for bribery has been published in the Law Quarterly Review and the Restitution Law Review.

Cases

Grid view
List view
Shortlist

Financial Services

Carmine accepts instructions in all areas of Chambers’ financial services law practice.  

Cases

Grid view
List view
Shortlist

Arbitration

Carmine accepts instructions in all areas of Chambers’ arbitration practice. 

Shortlist

Employment

Carmine accepts instructions in all areas of Chambers’ employment law practice. He has worked on cases before the Employment Tribunal, Employment Appeal Tribunal and High Court, involving issues regarding employment status, restrictive covenants, bonuses, whistleblowing, and unfair and wrongful dismissal.  Many of these matters are confidential, and so their details must be anonymised.

Cases

Grid view
List view
Shortlist

Public & Regulatory

Carmine accepts instructions in all areas of Chambers’ public and regulatory law practice. He has worked on public and administrative law matters before the High Court and Court of Appeal, for and against individuals, government and regulated entities.

Cases

Grid view
List view

Achievements

Education

Bachelor of Arts (First Class Honours) (University of Melbourne)

Bachelor of Laws (First Class Honours) (University of Melbourne)

Bachelor of Civil Law (Distinction) (University of Oxford)

Master of Philosophy in Law (University of Oxford), for the thesis 'Penalties and Forfeitures Reinterpreted'

Doctor of Philosophy in Law (University of Oxford), for the thesis 'Penalties Reworked: The Rule against Penalties Restated, Justified and Refined'

Bar Transfer Test (Top of Year) (BPP University)

Scholarships and awards

  • Allan Myers Oxford Law Faculty Scholarship (to read for the BCL)
  • Leggatt Melbourne Law Faculty Scholarship (for outstanding academic performance)
  • Highest ranked student (Advanced Torts, Contract Law, Civil Litigation, Political Theory, Property Law, Insolvency Law and Modern Political Thought)    

Publications

  • ‘Deposit Clauses’ in Graham Virgo and Sarah Worthington (eds), Commercial Remedies: Resolving Controversies (CUP 2017) 
  • ‘The Penalty Rule Revisited’ (2016) 142 LQR 382
  • ‘From Only the ‘Bottom-up’? Legitimate Forms of Judicial Reasoning in Private Law’ (2015) 35 OJLS 1
  • ‘No Proprietary Relief for Breach of Fiduciary Duty’ (2012) 128 LQR 184
  • 'The Death Knell Tolls for Attorney-General for Hong Kong v Reid’ [2012] RLR 118
  • ‘The Continued Obscurity of Economic Duress’ [2011] LMCLQ 333
  • ‘The Jurisdiction to Relieve Against Penalties and Forfeitures’ (2010) 126 LQR 529
  • Edwin Peel, Treitel on the Law of Contract (13th edn, Sweet and Maxwell 2011) (Research Assistant)

VAT registration number: 331021273

Clerks

Staff