On 3 November 2026, the Divisional Court handed down judgment in HM Attorney General for England and Wales v BBC [2026] EWHC 2802 (Admin) and R (Beth) v Investigatory Powers Tribunal (‘2026 judgment’).
The issue before the Court was whether the Court should, of its own initiative, initiate proceedings for contempt of court against any individual MI5 officers, the Director General of MI5, or MI5 itself, as a result of the giving of false evidence by MI5 to the High Court.
The background circumstances were described in the Court’s earlier judgment of 2 July 2025 ([2025] EWHC 1669 (KB)). MI5’s evidence to the High Court was that it had not departed from its “neither confirm nor deny” policy in relation to a covert human intelligence source referred to as “X”, who was the subject of an investigation by the BBC. This was untrue.
Following the July 2025 judgment, the Prime Minister directed the Investigatory Powers Commissioner to investigate, and the Commissioner appointed Sir John Goldring to carry out that investigation. Sir John conducted a thorough investigation in which he reviewed documents and interviewed 36 witnesses. The open version of his final report, which took into account comments from those criticised, was published on 16 July 2026.
The key conclusions in Sir John’s report were set out by the Court (2026 judgment, §§9-10, 27). They included conclusions that Officer 2 “throughout knew he had departed from NCND. His lies formed the foundation of MI5’s false account” and that another senior MI5 officer, Officer 3, had, through his conduct “significantly contributed to MI5’s initial false account” and bore “considerable responsibility” for MI5’s continued reliance on it. Sir John further concluded that “opportunities to correct the position” had been missed by MI5.
The Court observed that MI5 accepted Sir John’s findings, but Officers 2 and 3 did not. It considered Sir John’s findings were serious and may justify a “more searching approach” to corporate evidence from MI5 (2026 judgment, §§10-15).
On the issue arising for decision before it, however, the Court concluded that it would not be in the public interest to initiate contempt proceedings of its own motion. It concluded that if there was to be further action against either Officer 2 or Officer 3, it should follow a police investigation into possible criminal offences, and consideration by the CPS. The Court further concluded that there would be no public benefit in initiating contempt proceedings against the Director General of MI5, or MI5 itself (2026 judgment, §§16, 29, 34, 37-40).
The Divisional Court’s 2026 judgment is available here, and its press summary here.
The Divisional Court’s 2025 judgment is available here.
Sir John Goldring’s 2026 final open report is available here.
Tim Otty KC acted for MI5.
Charlotte Kilroy KC and Rachel Jones acted for ‘Beth’.


